Reprinted from The Medicine & Surgery Vol X XI I
I No. 2 February 1983
Paper presented at the Second Congress, Indian Society of Perinatology,
Reproductive Biology & Planned Parenthood, Jammu (J&K), 27-29, Sept.80.
Treatment Of Threatened Abortion With Progesterone And Leptaden And Outcome Of
Pregnancy
(A Controlled Study)
by
Dr. (Mrs) Florence S. Philips, DGO., FRCOG.,Professor 'of
Obst. & Gynaee., Madras Medical College, & Director and Superintendent,
Inst. of Obst. & Gynaec, & Govt. Hospital for Women & Children,
MADRAS-8
Miss Agnes Mary Poobalarayal, MD , DGO., Asst. Professor of Obst. & Gynaec.,
College & Hospital, TIRUNELVELI.
T.Nadu.
Introduction
Threatened Abortion is a
clinical entity characterized by symptoms of vaginal spotting and abdominal
discomfort in the absence of significant cervical dilatation.
Claims have been made about the beneficial effects of different
therapeutic regimes, varying from simple bed rest and sedation to the use
of vitamins and progesterones. About
30% of the untreated cases
abort at this stage.
The major
hormonal deficiency which may be held responsible for the loss of pregnancy
is the insufficient production of progesterone by the corpus Iuteum during
the early stages of pregnancy or by the placenta once it takes over the task
of secreting it. A hormonal deficiency involving progestogens in most likely to occur in
the first trimester of pregnancy at the time when the main output of progesterone
is taken over by the placenta from the corpus Iuteum. Pregnanedion is the chief metobolite of progesterone.The poor correlation between plasma
progesterone levels and the fetal state can be to some extent be accounted for
by the high variability of plasma progesterone levels from time to time in the
same subject. Progesterone is not made denovo in the placenta, but by enzymatic
transformation of maternal or fetal cholesterol on pregnaneolone. Even when
the fortus is dead the supply of precursor from maternal sources is enough to
maintain progesterone synthesis at a normal rate.
Place of Progesterone in Threatened Abortion
Progestational
agents are extensively used in an effort to salvage pregnancy in cases of threatened
abortion. A controversial report alleges a teratogenic effect (Phocomelia)
from progestational agents which are administered during pregnancy.
Progestational Replacement Therapy
Pregnanediol is
the chief metabolite of progesterone and is mainly excreted through urine. If
the pregnanediol urinary excretion is low for the stage of pregnancy, the pregnant
lady is given replacement therapy. Progesterone is administered as a capsule (Synerone), one capsule
3-4 times a day, up to 36 weeks or as Medroxy progesterone acetate, (Depot Provera)
80 mg/day in divided doses for 36 weeks. However, 11 alpha hydroxv
progesterons caproate is the drug commonly used as intramuscular inj. 250 mg500
mg weekly up to 36 weeks.
Objects Of The Study
The object
of this study was to analyze results of
the outcome of pregnancy in patients who were hospitalized for Threatened Abortion
and treated with Progesterone & Leptaden or Leptaden only. We also tried
to assess the usefulness of vaginal smear studies.
Leptaden
Each tablet of
Leptaden contains:
Jeevanti (Leptadenia
retieulata) : 150 mg.Kamboji (Breynia patents) : 150 mg.
Leptaden helps
proper implantation of fertilized ovum. Helps sustenance of pregnancy to Full
Term and ensures FTLB (Full Term Live Birth) and a child that survives and thrives.
Useful in the management of Threatened Abortion and High Risk Pregnancy and
in cases with bad obstetric history of Threatened Abortion, Habitual Abortion
and Premature Birth.
Table I : Review of Some
Research Studies on Leptaden
|
|
Series
|
Overall Observations
|
|
1.
|
Patel N.V. (1947).
|
Leptaden
has helped even in cases with history of 4-10 previous abortions.
|
|
2.
|
Naik M. C. (1957).
|
Even in some cases with
positive WR & Kahn tests (Syphilitic), results were surprisingly good. *
|
|
3.
|
Mangeshikar S.N. (1965).
|
Leptaden normalises environmental factors for proper
implantation of fertilised ovum.
|
|
4,
|
Patel M. C. (1965).
|
Leptaden helps to sustain
pregnancy to Full Term and a child that survives and thrives.*
|
|
5
|
Kamala Achari (1966 &
1975).
|
Leptaden gives better results than the conventional
therapy. Leptaden has no side effects and safe to the mother and child.
Simple dosage. No necessity for Laboratory tests to control the dosage
|
Table 1 I :
Success Rate In Cases Threatened Abortion : Some Studies.
Series FTLB (Full
Kamala
Achari (1975) .... 80% to 88%
Florence Philips (l977) .... 84.3°/ 0
Savitri &
Venkata Rao (1977) .. 82 5%
Saxena (1979) . . . . 86.2%
LEPTADEN: EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES
ON GUINEA PIGS
Leptaden inhibits Prostaglandin Fz alpha biosynthesis of the uterine tissue.
Experimental research
was done on Leptaden by Sharma at the Trinity College, Dublin (Ireland), guinea
pigs of known fertility. using latest sensitive radio-immunoassay methods,
he found that the amount of Prostaglandin FR alpha extracted from
the Leptaden treated group was significantly lower i that of untreated group,
while uterine weights of both the pro did not show any statistical difference.
This indicated that Leptaden inhibits F2 alpha biosynthesis a this helps to
prevent abortion since any increase to prostaglandins causes abortion or premature
delivery.
Materials & Methods
Only definite
cases of threaten abortion who were hospitalized v studied. Doubtful cases were
excluded from the study. The total number of cases studied were 110 they were
divided in two groups Group A, received Progesterone and Leptaden and Group
B received only Leptaden. There were 62 cases Group A ( Prog. + Lep. ), and
cases in Group B (only Leptaden Group). All 110 patients were given Leptaden
2 tabs. thrice daily from the day of admission for threaten abortion till full
term, or till spontaneous termination of pregnancy earlier. Group A, in addition to Leptaden received 17 alpha
hydroxy caproate 250 mg to 500 mg/week up to 36 weeks or till spontaneous termination
of pregnancy if earlier.Patients were aged between 18.
years. They belonged to primigravids to
para V. Patients admitted for threatened abortion had amenorrhoea ranging from
10 to 28 weeks.
Previous History of Abortion
on By
There were 42 patients with pa
history ofabortions and in 68 casE there was no previous history c abortion
(Primary Threatened Abo3 tion). The majority of cases ha one abortion before
(Table (II).
Table III : History of Previous Abortions
|
Abortions
before
|
No. of cases
|
|
|
One
abortion before :
|
21
|
19.1%
|
|
Two
abortions before :
|
11
|
10.0%
|
|
Three
abortions before :
|
|
4.5%
|
|
More
than three
abortions
before :
|
5
|
4.5%
|
|
No
previous history :
|
68
|
61.9%
|
|
Total
:
|
110
|
100.0%
|
Progestational Status based on Vaginal Cytology -
Vaginal cytology was done in all 110 cases of threatened
abortion after hospitalization. Based on vaginal cytology, the progestational
status was classified as Good, Fair and Poor. Twenty-ore patients (19.1%) had
Good progestational status, 24 patients (11.8%) had Fair progestational status
& 65 patients (59.1%) had Poor pragestational status. (Table IV)
Table
I V : Progestational Status based on vaginal cytology before treatment.
|
Prog.
Status
|
Group A
(Prog & Lep.) %
|
Group B
(Leptaden only) %
|
Total
|
%
|
|
Good
:
|
0
|
|
21
|
43.7%
|
21
|
19.1%
|
|
Fair
:
|
16
|
25.8%
|
8
|
16.7%
|
24
|
21.8%
|
|
Poor
:
|
46
|
74.2%
|
19
|
39.6%
|
65
|
59.1%
|
|
Total
:
|
62
|
140.0%
|
48
|
100.0%
|
110
|
100.0%
|
Table V Outcome of pregnancy in cases of Threatened
Abortion
Group A (Prog. & Lep) & Group B (only
Lep)
|
Outcome
of
pregnancy
|
Group A
(Prog. &
Lep) %
|
Group B
(Only Leptaden) %
|
|
Progressed
to Full Term
|
49
|
79.0%
|
35
|
72.9%
|
|
Preterm
delivery
|
2
|
32%
|
5
|
10.4%
|
|
Ended
in Abortion
|
11
|
17.' %
|
8
|
16,7%
|
|
Total
:
|
62
|
100.0%
|
|
100.0%
|
Dosage Regimen of Leptaden & Progesterone
Leptaden : All the 110 cases of Threatened Abortion were given Leptaden
2 tabs thrice daily till full term or up to spontaneous termination of pregnancy
if earlier.
Progesterone ; Sixty-two cases of
Group A, received, Leptaden, 2 tabs thrice daily & 17 alpha hydroxy caproate
i.m. 250 mg-500 mg once a week up to ?6 weeks of pregnancy. This treatment was
stopped if there was any spontaneous termination of pregnancy before full term.
Outcome of Pregnancy in Threatened Abortion : Group A (Progesterone
and Leptaden) And Group B (Only Leptaden)
Among 62
cases of Group A (Prog & Lep.) there was Full Term Delivery in 49 cases
(79.0%). Among 48 cases of Group B who received only Leptaden, 35 cases (72.9%)
had Full Term Delivery. The advantage of Prog. & Leptaden combined therapy
was 6.1%. The abortion rate in both the groups was about the same, thus indicating
the addition of progesterone had not helped in the decrease of abortions in
cases of Threatened Abortion. As such, in the treatment of Threatened Abortion
where facilities for investigations are not available, Leptaden therapy can
beneficially be used without hormonal treatment.The details of outcomeof pregnancy in Group A (Prog. &
Lep.) and in Group B (only Lep.) are given in Table V.
Outcome of Pregnancy with
Reference to Progestational Status.
Group
A (Leptaden & Progesterone):
In this group
patients having good progestational status were not included as they did not
require progesterone replacement therapy. There were 16 cases with Fair progestatienal
status and 46 patients with poor progestational status. Out of 16 cases of Fair
Progestational status of this group, 14 patients (87.50%) had Full Term
delivery, one was pre-term (6.25%) and there was one abortion (6.25%).
Out of 46 patients with Poor progestational
status, 35 patients (76.09%) had Full Term delivery, one was pre-term (2.17%)
and 10 patients (21.74%) had abortion. The overall Full Term delivery rate was
79.0% Table VI)
Table VI : Outcome of pregnancy with reference to progestational
Status
Group A (Lep + Prog )
Proa.
Full term% before Term
treatment
|
Prog. Status before treatment
|
Group A
(Lep. & Prog )
|
Full Term
|
%
|
Premature Delivery
|
%
|
Abortion
|
|
|
Good :
|
-
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Fair :
|
16
|
14
|
87.50%
|
1
|
6.25%
|
1
|
6.25%
|
|
Poor :
|
46
|
35
|
76.09%
|
|
2.17%
|
10
|
21.74%
|
|
Total :
|
62
|
49
|
79.0%
|
|
3.2 %
|
11
|
17.8%
|
Outcome of Pregnancy with Reference to
Progestational Status:
Group B
(Leptaden
only)In the Leptaden Group (Group B)
of 48 patients, 21 patients had Good progestational status before starting the
treatment. Out of these 21 patients, 19 (90.4%) had Full Term delivery, one
pre-term delivery (4.8%) and 1 abortion(4.8%). Out of 8 patients having Fair
progestational status 7 patients (87.5) had Full Term delivery, one pre-term
and there was no
abortion. Out of 19
patients who had Poor progestational status, 9 patients (47.4%) had Full Term
delivery, 3 patients (15.8%) had pre-term delivery and 7 patients (36.8%) had
abortion.The overall Full Term delivery rate in the Leptaden alone
Group was 72.9% (Table VII).
Table VII : Group B : Outcome of Leptaden only Group :
Pregnancy With reference to progestational status.
Premature Delivery
%
Abortion %
|
Progest
erone statue
before
treatment
|
Group B,
only
Lep,
Group
|
Full
Term
|
%
|
Preterm
|
%
|
Abortion
|
%
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Good :
|
21
|
l9
|
90.4%
|
1
|
48%
|
1
|
4.8%
|
|
Fair :
|
8
|
7
|
87.5%
|
1
|
12.5%
|
0
|
-
|
|
Poor :
|
19
|
9
|
47.4%
|
|
15.8%
|
7
|
36.8%
|
|
Total :
|
48
|
35
|
729%
|
5
|
10 4%
|
8
|
6.7%
|
Discussion
In Group
A where Leptaden and progesterone were used, Full Term delivery rate was 79.0%,
while in B, where Leptaden alone
was used, the pregnancy rate was 72.9%. The advantage of addition of progesterone
was to the extent of 6.1%. However, in Full Term and Pre-term deliveries are
taken together, Leptaden alone Group showed 83.3% of Live Births and Leptaden
and progesterone group showed 82.2% Live Births, thus showing the success rate
in both the Groups are nearly the same. Abortion rate in Prog. & Leptaden
Group was 17.8% while in the Leptaden alone group was 16.7%, thus showing the
abortion rates in both the groups did not differ much.This study has shown that addition
of progesterone therapy by way of i.m. inj. of 17 alpha hydroxy caproate once
a week for 36 week along with Leptaden therapy has not shown any appreciable
difference in salvage rate when compared only Leptaden therapy. The beneficial
effect of Leptaden therapy over the combined treatment better appreciated, as
19 patient (39.6%) of this group had Poor progesterone status. Hence it is concluded
that the salvage rate with Leptaden alone is equally good when compared to the
progesterone combined therapy. This will be particular benefit in the management
of Threatened Abortion where Vaginal cytology, progestetional
status and other investigations cannot be done for want of facilities.
Type of Deliveries: ! nfai
Mortality :
Out of 110 cases, (both group:
there were 91 Live births, with 'Full Term deliveries and 7 Pre-ter
deliveries. There was spontaneous abortion in 19 patients in spite of
treatment.
Caesarian
delivery had to be done in 11 patients of Full Term deliver Among the 7
pre-term babies gestational age of 32-36 weeks, the weight of the babies ranged
fro 1.8 kg. to 2.3
kg. Out of these 5 survived. Among the 2 babies that died, one died due to
Abruptio Placenta (Group A) and the other one died due to placenta praevia.
(Group B)
Of the Full Term
babies, 2 babies (Group A) died, one due to asphyxia neonatorum and another
due to imminent eclampsia. In Group A, there were 3 perinatal deaths while in
Group B there was one perinatal death.Full
Term delivery rate in the progesterone group was 79.0% while it was 72.9% which
is slightly less an the former group. If these patients had not received any
therapy, the salvage rate would have been far less and many would have ended
in inevitable abortion.
The Uterine cramps
of threatened abortion were quickly brought under control with Leptaden and
this was probably due to anti-proatoglandin effect of Leptaden.
Conclusions &
Summary;
Definite cases
of Threatened Abortion were divided into two groups. A & B. Group A (62
patients) received progesterone and Leptaden and Group B (48 patients) received
only Leptaden.Vaginal Cytology and Urinary Pregnanediol
estimation were done in all the 110 cases to assess the progestational status.Group
A received Leptaden and Progesterone (17 alpha hydroxy caproate) weekly injections
i.m., Group B was given only Leptaden.Full Term delivery rate was
79.0% in Group A (Prog. & Lep.) while it was 72.9% in Group B (Only Leptaden),
but when pre-term deliveries were included, there was no appreciable difference
between both the groups, as to Live Birth rate. (Group A 82.2% and Group B 83.3%)Considering
the side effects of hormonal treatment and the necessity to monitor Pregnanediol
and progesterone values before and during the hormonal treatment, Leptaden a
non hormonal and a safe herbal drug requires no such special and sophisticated
tests during its useIn cases of Threatened Abortion Leptaden can
beneficially be used without hormonal treatment, and requires no tests.There
were no toxic or side effects and Leptaden is found to be safe to both mother
and child.
Acknowledgement
Thanks to Alarsin
Pharmaceuticals, Bombay, for their co-operation.
References :
1 Mrs. Achari,
Kamala and Sinha, Renu (1966) : Treatment of Threatened and Recurrent Abortions
(A Clinical Study of 2 cases with Leptaden) Patna J. of Medicine, XXX (I"January
1966.
2
Mrs. Achari, Kamala (1975) : Use of Leptaden in High Risk Pregnancy. 2nd International
Seminar on Maternal and Peri. natal Mortality, Pregnancy Termination and Sterilisation,
Bombay 3-5 March, 1975.
3 Bhatia, Geeta I. (1979): Leptaden in the prevention of Habitual abortion or
Premature delivery. 23rd All India
Obst. & Gynec., Congress, Bangalore 29-31, Dec. 1979 and Current Med. Pract. 26 : 8, p. 233-36,
August 1982
4 Mangeshikar, S. N. (1957) : LEPTADEN in Habitual Abortions. 34th
All India MedicalConference, Bangalore, 1957 & Antiseptic. Vol.
55, No. 7, p.487 494, July 1958.
5 Naik, M.G. (1957) ; Preliminary observations on the use of a» Indian Indigenous
Drug in certain Uterine Haemorrhages. Indian Practitioner, 10 : l, Jan. 1957.
6 Patel, Mahendra C. (1965) : Leptaclen in Idiopathic Habitual Abortions
( A Clinical Study ). Current Med. Practice, 9 : 12, Dec.
1965.
7 Patel, N. V. (1947) : A Suggestion to Gynaecologists. Antiseptic, 44 : 6,
p 377-380, June 1947.
8 Mrs. Philips, Florence S. (1977) : Clinicnl trial with Leptaden for Recurrent
and Threatened Abortions and Premature Labour. Current Med. Pract. 21 (7),
p.3'.7 320, July 1977.
9 Mrs. Savithrif C. and Venkata Rao, N. (1977) :Role of Leptaden during Pregnancy.
XXI All India Obst. & Gynec. Congress, Cuttack, 27-29, Dec. 1977 and Bombay
Hosp J. Vol. 23 (4), pp.28-32, October 1981.
10 Saxena, S.C. (1977)
: Role of Leptaden as a Tocolytic agent for prevention of Untimely Interruption
of Pregnancy, XXX All India Obst. & Gyuec. Congress, Cuttack, 27-29, Dec.
1977 and Medicine & Surgery, 19 : 3, p.5-1 l, March 1979.
11 Sharma S.C. (1976) : A Possible Mechanism of Leptaden Action by
Inhibiting prostaglandin F2a synthesis. Ind. J. Me(] Res. 64 ; 4, p.597-600,
April 1976.